To MSTS or not.

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • charland
    3000 Post Veteran


    • Dec 2006
    • 3107
    • Brockville, ON, CA
    • General

    #16
    I think there is a bit of difference between an entirely new sim with their own formatting and Open Rails that was born as a replacement for MSTS but was to be compatible with older MSTS routes and rolling stock. I guess some of us assumed that was still a goal but there are some people who are currently pushing for just about every file format to change, even the elimination of using "s" files which would render ever route and object in the libraries obsolete. What these people want it for Open Rails to basically become another sim with all new formats like every other new sim.

    Paul

    Comment

    • slipperman
      3500 Post Veteran



      • May 2010
      • 3787
      • Worksop, UK
      • MSOR

      #17
      Hi geepster775,
      I respect your views, but those other sims were developed as completely separate entities with their own stock, routes and activities. The ideas for them may well have come from the success of MSTS but Open Rails 'piggy-backed' on MSTS using all of its original file formats. That is good from the user's point of view due to the vast array of MSTS add-ons available Worldwide, most of which perform as well as, if not better, under Open Rails.

      You seem to want Open Rails to be developed into a separate simulator. That's fine, but where are the resources for creating its own stock and routes coming from?

      The success of Open Rails, up to now, has been, I suspect, due to many users being unable to run MSTS on Windows 10 or 11 (for whatever reasons). Separating OR without a full array of specific add-ons will, I feel, kill it stone dead!

      Just my twopennyworth!!
      Cheers,
      Ged


      Comment

      • cjakeman
        Senior Member
        • Mar 2010
        • 137

        #18
        Hi Paul,

        Originally posted by charland
        I think there is a bit of difference between an entirely new sim with their own formatting and Open Rails that was born as a replacement for MSTS but was to be compatible with older MSTS routes and rolling stock. I guess some of us assumed that was still a goal but there are some people who are currently pushing for just about every file format to change, even the elimination of using "s" files which would render ever route and object in the libraries obsolete.
        Our policy for staying compatible with older MSTS content has not changed and is stated on the website at http://openrails.org/contribute/team-policies/

        2023-07-22 18_49_39-Open Rails - Contribute - Team Policies — Mozilla Firefox.jpg

        I hope that gives you confidence that older content will not be abandoned.
        Chris Jakeman

        sigpic

        Comment

        • BrandonS261
          Senior Member



          • Apr 2019
          • 307
          • Twin Cities
          • ORTS

          #19
          Now when it comes to MSTS and Open Rails yes Open Rails has full advantage over MSTS but still has a ways to go in some areas! That being said I think it would be devastating for Open Rails to completely go away from MSTS file formats.

          So many creators have spent months if not years creating MSTS/Open Rails content for all of us to enjoy and if we were to completely go away from MSTS file formats we would have to start all over with new content that many of us either do not want to create again or do not want to mess with re creating stuff that has already been available to all of us. Along with many who are no longer with us or have created magnificent models that have gone away from MSTS/Open Rails.

          Remember the old saying if it ant broke don't fix it! That is MSTS to Open Rails. Yes we may be using old file formats that are over 20 years old but they still work just fine for what many of us want and need. Sure Open Rails is not as advanced in some aspect of the rail simulator world as others like graphics, lighting and a few other parts but it has the edge when it comes to physics and that is why I stick with Open Rails VS other rail simulators.

          If you do not like the way Open Rails is going by all means go to another railroad simulator that suits your needs. There are many of them out there.

          Just my two cense in this whole thread and hope the Open Rails team along with others understand where I am coming from!

          Brandon

          Comment

          • R. Steele
            3500 Post Veteran

            • Feb 2013
            • 3928
            • known universe
            • ORTS

            #20
            I think this topic is just another quarterly ( approx. ) example of a "tempest in a teapot" "get your popcorn" topic. The original post was definitely directed towards route creation exclusively for MSTS or OR...which one? ( common sense and an acute appreciation of progress would dictate OR )

            First sentence of thread:
            After all these years of route building I'm thinking it's time to stop worrying about making routes that work in both MSTS and OR.
            It quickly careened off into the usual tiresome misinformed grumbling about Open Rails vs whatever person posting had a complaint about.
            Geeeeze...get a grip.

            Really the discussion should have been a reasoned examination of TSRE vs MSTS_RE and how to move worthwhile functions of both into an integrated Route Editor for Open Rails. How to attract coders and other worthwhile subjects.
            ​
            Cheers, Gerry
            "A mind is like a parachute. It doesn't work if it is not open." Frank Zappa
            It's my railroad and I'll do what I want! Historically accurate attitude of US Railroad Barons.
            Forever, ridin' drag in railroad knowledge.
            Audi, Vide, Tace, Si Vis Vivere In Pace​

            https://www.trainsim.com/forums/filedata/fetch?filedataid=79656&type=medium​ https://www.trainsim.com/forums/filedata/fetch?filedataid=79654&type=small

            Comment

            • jbtower
              Senior Member


              • Jul 2005
              • 573
              • Yorkville, Illinois, USA.
              • ORTS

              #21
              Well said Gerry!
              Kevin Kelleher

              Comment

              • charland
                3000 Post Veteran


                • Dec 2006
                • 3107
                • Brockville, ON, CA
                • General

                #22
                OK, the reason for my original post...

                I'm just finishing off a route. Over the years I've tried to make sure my route were compatible with MSTS because there are still people out there using it. I have one tile that includes half of Amsterdam NY and now includes a new industrial park (new to me is the mid-1970s!). I was able to add the park, roads, rails, building but had little left for vehicles and greenery as I was already at 1500 objects. Changing the route to OR only did make sense as it would (has) allowed me to complete the tile as I wanted it, coming out at around 1750 objects and therefore it's no longer compatible with MSTS.

                Sometimes you have to say this stuff out loud just to see if anyone objects.

                Paul :-)

                Comment

                • CSRX
                  13500 Post Veteran



                  • Oct 2005
                  • 13649
                  • Lincoln, ME
                  • English
                  • ORTS

                  #23
                  Originally posted by eric

                  Are things being broken, or are workarounds for the MSTS flaws being overridden (e.g. million ton coupler strength)?

                  I've never been one for the physics or steam firing accuracy, but I do remember Plainsman physics being a fad/movement 15 years ago. How is whats happening with newer ORTS parameters any different, aside from being supported vs. constrained by the game engine or BIN?
                  No, definitely becoming broken. Just look at all the issues that pop up within these forums of issues such as the horizon problems, or the sun issues. I'm not talking about just physics here. Though honestly even physics wise, you end up going back and re-editing it because the next installment makes the previous physics act wonky. Example, I put effort into making my rolling stock have more realistic slack action. Worked well before, but with 1.5.1, it acts spongy, so I scrapped that idea all together. That doesn't even dive into the big changes you need to dive further into between 1.5.1 and MG or the experimental versions. Chasing your tail around in circles gets real old real quick, seems like every single time ORTS updates, you need to go back and adjust things again you have previously smoothed out to work just fine. Obviously some people here don't truly understand that concept, and just tell developers to "get a grip".
                  Well, part of the reason I gave up producing anything.

                  Then there are the "include files" which are an extreme hit or miss on whether they will actually work or not. Did the same adjustments to two locomotives with the shape engine files and shapes, one worked, the other did not, once I deleted the include files out of the engine file for the one that didn't work, it worked again, and they were done exactly the same.

                  ORTS page may say will always be compatible, but honestly, how truthful is that, when you constantly have to go in and edit your files to work for the next installment? Honestly, that why I find myself completely burnt out and have zero interest in the sim, and to be truthful, it sounds like I am not the only one that feels this way, however I am the only one to actually say something about it rather than stepping away silently, though I feel certain folks here would prefer the second part from me..

                  Now, I will say, TSRE wise, miles ahead of the original RE. I may not have ever released a route, but learning and building seemed to be so much easier and smoother in TSRE without major crashing issues. A huge bonus too when you can completely max out scenery and it still handles just fine. Even going into the route of choice and adding gravel or extra ballast to the road bed is a breeze with TSRE. Done that with many of Paul's fantastic routes, and done so with some of my own and others like the KHP v2 from MLT.

                  I was just saying, eventually ORTS will be left behind too, but apparently that was just upsetting the diehard fans as usual.
                  Last edited by CSRX; 07-22-2023, 15:12.
                  -Shawn K-
                  MEC Mountain Subdivision - Trackwork 70%, Scenery 35%
                  ​

                  Comment

                  • R. Steele
                    3500 Post Veteran

                    • Feb 2013
                    • 3928
                    • known universe
                    • ORTS

                    #24
                    Originally posted by charland
                    OK, the reason for my original post...

                    Sometimes you have to say this stuff out loud just to see if anyone objects.

                    Paul :-)
                    ​

                    Why would anyone object? Why the concern about producing new content for an early 2000s PC game -- I see no indication of anyone producing new content for any other popular 2000s PC games -- except in train simulators -- specifically MSTS...now why is that?

                    There's always going to be someone interested in trying to load up MSTS or an early version of Grand Theft Auto and trying to make it work. If it happens to be MSTS that they are trying to fire up and are successful, they will find --- hundreds, if not thousands of items world-wide that are available to them --- adding one more is ---well, frankly pointless.

                    I'm reasonably confident that 25 years from now there will still be train simulators available, will one of them be OR -- I have no idea, but if it is, it will -- more than likely -- have little resemblance to the OR we are familiar with.

                    (as a public aside to Paul: I wasn't specifically addressing my comments towards you, the FJ&G was one of the first routes I ran, and was immediately impressed with the craftsmanship and attention to detail...masterful. Whatever you turn your considerable skills to, will always be welcomed...so push forward and create -- using contemporary tools worthy of the craftsman )
                    Cheers, Gerry
                    "A mind is like a parachute. It doesn't work if it is not open." Frank Zappa
                    It's my railroad and I'll do what I want! Historically accurate attitude of US Railroad Barons.
                    Forever, ridin' drag in railroad knowledge.
                    Audi, Vide, Tace, Si Vis Vivere In Pace​

                    https://www.trainsim.com/forums/filedata/fetch?filedataid=79656&type=medium​ https://www.trainsim.com/forums/filedata/fetch?filedataid=79654&type=small

                    Comment

                    • eric
                      9500 Post Veteran and Administrator



                      • Dec 2002
                      • 9587
                      • NS MP245.4 CNO&TP South District
                      • English, SQL
                      • General

                      #25
                      Lets stop making this personal, folks...

                      Chris is a spokesperson for the ORMT. Lets take his statement at face value, and if you're not reporting issues back to to the dev team, you should consider it. As someone all to acquainted with errant code having unintended consequences, we all make mistakes and need the extra eyes and hands on keyboards to find them.
                      If you like what you see here at Trainsim.com, be it the discussions and knowledge in the forums, or items available in our library, I hope you'll consider a paid membership to help support keeping the site operating.... Thanks!

                      Comment

                      • eric
                        9500 Post Veteran and Administrator



                        • Dec 2002
                        • 9587
                        • NS MP245.4 CNO&TP South District
                        • English, SQL
                        • General

                        #26
                        Reopening in the hopes that the discussion can stay objective.......
                        If you like what you see here at Trainsim.com, be it the discussions and knowledge in the forums, or items available in our library, I hope you'll consider a paid membership to help support keeping the site operating.... Thanks!

                        Comment

                        • ebnertra000
                          1500 Post Veteran


                          • Jun 2013
                          • 1778
                          • Minnesota

                          #27
                          At this point in time, I don't see a point in making what little new content is created these days compatible with MSTS. If it works there anyway, great; if not, I'm not losing any sleep over it. For all its faults, the future is here. I dropped the compatibility requirement in my own creations some time ago, and haven't had any issues yet

                          Comment

                          • pwillard
                            3000 Post Veteran



                            • Nov 1999
                            • 3071
                            • Cumming Ga
                            • ORTS

                            #28
                            Man, I totally get the burnout that comes with trying to make things work in MSTS or even ORTS. I haven't really had MSTS working on my PC for a few years now and really can't be bothered.

                            Actually, I often reach the point where I look at what I'm doing and think "Why am I bothering at all?" (It explains my 50 or so unfinished projects) I mean, for comparison, it's like going through all the trouble of having a LIVE STREAM on youtube and 8 people show up. Our US/EU rail audience is now super small... though seemingly seldom satisfied with what little non-Indian railway content gets produced unless it's NAVS or from Shawn. Thankfully though most of the gimme-pigs have moved on.

                            Open Rails, in hanging on to most of the things that made MSTS work ends up stifling itself with the inability to really improve anymore. Compare that with TRAINZ, where each new release seems to say "We will only provide limited support for older releases and will make certain features obsolete as we see fit. If your old stuff works, great. If not, oh well". It may seem callous on the surface, but they now have PBR Textures (Textures with Depth) which make a huge difference.

                            The ORTS team is small and made up of volunteers. They work on what they can, when they can, and are very reluctant to make huge sweeping changes. We are years and years behind state-of-the-art with ORTS but that is the price we pay for FREE and OPEN SOURCE for such a niche item.

                            http://www.railsimstuff.com
                            Just Blender now, 3DCrafter only when I have to.
                            Formerly The Keystone Works (All Permissions Granted)
                            Things I work on: https://github.com/pwillard

                            Comment

                            • EldoradoRailroad
                              Senior Member

                              • May 2010
                              • 212

                              #29
                              On this side of the screen, what I see in the OP is do I continue compatibility with MSTS or not? The answer to that question is really up to you. What I will say is that any effort to upgrade your modelling skills, texturing skills, etc to 202x "standards" is greatly appreciated, at least speaking for myself and what I would download. As mentioned elsewhere, ORTS only exists because MSTS had legible file structures. ORTS only exists because original MSTS content was "made" to work in ORTS. Have other sims eclipsed MSTS in terms of visual quality, I would say yes. Have other sims been as "open" as MSTS/ORTS, the answer is a firm "NO". Do other sims allow for almost infinite modification, the answer is a firm "NO".

                              So when you invest your time and money, in the newer sims, you are also committing yourself to "built in" end of life. Barring creative thinking, and overcoming DRM gymnastics, all those sims are destined for the trash can, when the rights holders give up on their business model. I cannot think of any reason why I would want to do that with my time and money, especially since the costs over time are not trivial at all. So as I have mentioned so very often, be very glad that for better or for worse, MSTS had a legible file structure, that we could reverse engineer, and that thus far, copyright jurisprudence has not descended on this open source hobby of ours to kill what little joy (at times) it seems to impart. Do I hope that ORTS will move forward with OPEN standards and updated OPEN/LEGIBLE standards, I cannot think of a reason to say "I hope not".

                              Steve

                              Comment

                              • Coonskin
                                3000 Post Veteran

                                • Aug 2002
                                • 3226
                                • Poteau, OK, USA.

                                #30
                                It would be nice if ORTS was actually fully compatible with MSTS as it sits, but if that was a goal, it was never fully realized before it started adding more features unique to ORTS.

                                What would have been great would have been for there to have been a final, optimized MSTS-compatable version of ORTS that was so noted and posted for the long term, and then ORTS made its break to go down whatever path it wanted to.

                                Years ago, I had hoped for the above: A final product that had functioning essentials within the MSTS platform, then make the break and take ORTS off into the sunrise.That way, those of us that intend to keep MSTS on the hard drive for as long as practical, have an operational platform that can be used for another decade or more.

                                However, I think it's too late for that.

                                In all the improvements to ORTS, and there have been many, it is still stuck with incomplete environment characteristics, poorly done smoke, etc, in the meantime work continues within ORTS that further obfuscate operating physics, etc. I simply gave up trying to keep up with it.
                                ​
                                I have my reasons for desiring to retain the use of MSTS for the foreseeable future that I won't go into, so no need to point out supposed MSTS shortcomings/etc to me.
                                Andre Ming
                                V Scale Creations.com R.I.P

                                Comment

                                Working...