To MSTS or not.

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • charland
    3000 Post Veteran


    • Dec 2006
    • 3107
    • Brockville, ON, CA
    • General

    #1

    To MSTS or not.

    After all these years of route building I'm thinking it's time to stop worrying about making routes that work in both MSTS and OR. I'm finishing up a route that combines the FJ&G and the ACN routes. As it is right now it would work in both MSTS and OR but I added the small industrial park that's just east of Amsterdam and it's on the same tile as half of Amsterdam. I hit the 1500 object limit but would like to add more vehicles to the parking lots of the businesses in the industrial park. This would make the route OR only.

    Is anyone out there actually still using MSTS and not OR? If so, why?

    Paul :-)
  • rdayt
    1000 Post Veteran

    • Nov 2007
    • 1291
    • SW MO
    • ORTS

    #2
    It's time to move on.
    I can no longer get parts for my truck from the manufacturer and it's newer than MSTS.
    To many limitations trying to stick with software that was abandoned 20 years ago.

    Randy

    Comment

    • jbtower
      Senior Member


      • Jul 2005
      • 573
      • Yorkville, Illinois, USA.
      • ORTS

      #3
      I quit using MSTS after loosing everything years back and have never looked backwards!!!!
      Kevin Kelleher

      Comment

      • dcarleton
        1000 Post Veteran


        • Nov 2008
        • 1006
        • MSOR

        #4
        It's kinda like keeping an analog TV after all the programing in your region has gone digital. Sure you can keep it, but going forward you're not going to need it.

        Comment

        • landnrailroader
          4000 Post Veteran



          • Nov 1999
          • 4172
          • Jacksonville,, FL, USA.
          • ORTS

          #5
          When I upgraded my main PC to Win-10 a month ago, I could not get MSTS loaded on it. I still have it on a backup machine running Win-XP. So, time to learn TSRE and the more I use it the better I like it. So far I have laid about 30 miles of the long gone Milwaukee Road from Great Falls to Agawam without any serious issues. Since all I have to do is key in the percent of grade that I need for each piece, rather than run those number mills in MSTS, laying of gradients and most importantly, changes in grade go much faster. I have no !@#$%^&*() use however for the way that TSRE creates cuts and embankments so I will use the XP machine for that purpose. I'll also use the XP Machine for compressing routes. I won't consciously create ORTS only routes but I have two routes that have some error in them, nobody has been able to find, that crashes MSTS on certain world tiles so those will be branded ORTS only.

          J. H. Sullivan
          (aka landnrailroader)

          Comment

          • charland
            3000 Post Veteran


            • Dec 2006
            • 3107
            • Brockville, ON, CA
            • General

            #6
            There are a few things that can be done better in MSTS Route Editor. The first time I used TRSE to place mileposts was on the DARv3 south of Digby. There is a long "S" curve that's pushing four miles long. Did the usual method of placing a signal, then started running an RDC with the compass showing and took a screenshot each time I was a mile closer to the signal. The first few looked reasonable but the fourth was over two miles away from the nearest track... that's when I went back to doing mileposts in MSTS!

            Pretty much knew the answer to my question when I posted it, just wanted to hear it out loud. I'll finish the tile on the east side of Amsterdam properly and post the route as "OR Only".

            Paul :-)

            Comment

            • gammaray84
              Senior Member
              • Dec 2018
              • 180

              #7
              Yes, it's time to move on from MSTS. For me it took few month or so, but it was worth it and i can safely say, not that interested looking back. Sure nostalgia and all that, but lucky for us Open Rails still reads msts files....

              Have a good day. 👏

              Comment

              • CSRX
                13500 Post Veteran



                • Oct 2005
                • 13649
                • Lincoln, ME
                • English
                • ORTS

                #8
                Eventually it will be time to move on from ORTS too, especially if it constantly gets changed, and everything you are currently working on, becomes broken, and you are in a never-ending cycle to keep those items or routes, in line with the current ORTS system... Really burns you out after a while..
                -Shawn K-
                MEC Mountain Subdivision - Trackwork 70%, Scenery 35%
                ​

                Comment

                • charland
                  3000 Post Veteran


                  • Dec 2006
                  • 3107
                  • Brockville, ON, CA
                  • General

                  #9
                  Ya, I hear you Shawn. With all the changes people want it won't be long before OR no longer will run anything in the library!

                  Paul :-)

                  Comment

                  • dcarleton
                    1000 Post Veteran


                    • Nov 2008
                    • 1006
                    • MSOR

                    #10
                    Correct. They are allowing the Perfect to become the enemy of the Good.

                    Comment

                    • slipperman
                      3500 Post Veteran



                      • May 2010
                      • 3787
                      • Worksop, UK
                      • MSOR

                      #11
                      Hi Paul and dcarleton,
                      I'm pleased somebody has said that because it has been my feeling for some time!

                      There seem to be attempts to make Open Rails as realistic as possible whereas all I, at least, need is a reasonable representation of reality. So long as the throttle and brakes work sensibly, I don't need to know the different effects of cast iron and fibre (or whatever) brake shoes, or to have to wait ages for the brakes of a long train to release. There are so many different new parameters, with strings of numbers with, frankly, mean nothing to most of us. As dear old Otto used to say, KISS, keep it simple, stupid. The .eng file parameters in MSTS are relatively easy to understand although probably too far removed from reality for some users, but at !east a degree in mathematics isn't needed to tweak them!! There are some very good elements in OR, for example, turntables, but if it continues in its current direction, it could well lose its popularity.

                      It's important to remember that without MSTS there wouldn't be Open Rails and we'd have to use Train Simulator 20xx. Or, maybe, if MSTS didn't exist, we wouldn't have that, either!!

                      Cheers,
                      Ged

                      Comment

                      • eric
                        9500 Post Veteran and Administrator



                        • Dec 2002
                        • 9587
                        • NS MP245.4 CNO&TP South District
                        • English, SQL
                        • General

                        #12
                        Originally posted by CSRX
                        Eventually it will be time to move on from ORTS too, especially if it constantly gets changed, and everything you are currently working on, becomes broken, and you are in a never-ending cycle to keep those items or routes, in line with the current ORTS system... Really burns you out after a while..
                        Are things being broken, or are workarounds for the MSTS flaws being overridden (e.g. million ton coupler strength)?

                        I've never been one for the physics or steam firing accuracy, but I do remember Plainsman physics being a fad/movement 15 years ago. How is whats happening with newer ORTS parameters any different, aside from being supported vs. constrained by the game engine or BIN?
                        If you like what you see here at Trainsim.com, be it the discussions and knowledge in the forums, or items available in our library, I hope you'll consider a paid membership to help support keeping the site operating.... Thanks!

                        Comment

                        • geepster775
                          2500 Post Veteran


                          • Sep 2006
                          • 2846
                          • .
                          • General

                          #13
                          Originally posted by charland
                          With all the changes people want it won't be long before OR no longer will run anything in the library!

                          Was there equal concern when it was first discovered that T:ANE, Run8, and TSW had orphaned all this legacy MSTS material in the file library? Why does it set off alarm bells only when ORTS development needs trigger the same outcome?

                          Something to ponder over.
                          My Open Rails videos https://www.youtube.com/@lakecities3663/videos

                          Comment

                          • geepster775
                            2500 Post Veteran


                            • Sep 2006
                            • 2846
                            • .
                            • General

                            #14
                            I think it behooves all contributors to start viewing their products as much more perishable (possessing a finite shelf life) than most seem willing to embrace at the moment.
                            My Open Rails videos https://www.youtube.com/@lakecities3663/videos

                            Comment

                            • geepster775
                              2500 Post Veteran


                              • Sep 2006
                              • 2846
                              • .
                              • General

                              #15
                              Originally posted by slipperman

                              It's important to remember that without MSTS there wouldn't be Open Rails

                              It is important to remember that without MSTS, there would be no Trainz, Railworks, TS20xx, Run8, and TSWx either. But nobody goes around expecting these newer franchises to be required to always 'pay historical dues' to MSTS and remain somewhat KISSy compliant. If these other products are free to develop their own code base, file formats, graphics engines, physics, and are free to be cut loose from paying daily homage to the king daddy that started it all, then Open Rails deserves the same opportunity to be a self-standing product. The MSTS users who were comfortable with doing things different or who wanted different physics, environments, piracy-resistant file formats, and god forbid, more than one cone of light, took flight long ago as these other franchises emerged, leaving behind a doty old pool of the less-reluctant users. I'm still waiting for this doty old pool of less reluctants to demand greater historical interconnection to MSTS out of the Run8 or TSW developers. I won't hold my breath.

                              We really do need to stop identifying Open Rails as a unique product that should carry this extra burden to remain historically connected to the past.

                              I don't care what people's desires are when it comes to enjoying legacy content. I just disapprove of their troubleshooting needs consuming so much ORTS users time when it does not equally consume a Run8 or TSW or T:ANE users time. Do what you want, but stay in your lane - after you reconcile that MSTS and ORTS are indeed different lanes now.​
                              My Open Rails videos https://www.youtube.com/@lakecities3663/videos

                              Comment

                              Working...