DW's Registration Code

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • trainman_47
    Senior Member
    • Sep 2005
    • 984
    • .Texas

    #76
    I guess the bottom line is simply this: Scott IS a very good modeler for MSTS / OR. It's a damn shame he can't be that way as a person. If he want's to sell any volume at all regarding payware, he had better either change his tune, or give it up!

    Comment

    • wcl
      Senior Member
      • May 2010
      • 417

      #77
      Originally posted by trainman_47
      I guess the bottom line is simply this: Scott IS a very good modeler for MSTS / OR. It's a damn shame he can't be that way as a person. If he want's to sell any volume at all regarding payware, he had better either change his tune, or give it up!

      He gave it up a long time ago, and now we just get the shaft on all his work!!! He left us hanging out to dry

      Comment

      • R. Steele
        3500 Post Veteran

        • Feb 2013
        • 3928
        • known universe
        • ORTS

        #78
        JMOFWIW
        My life has taught me that what you experience in the world and see in others is most often a reflection of your own inner reality.
        I have encountered a really good group of helpful, generous, courteous people on all the train forums and boards and (importantly for the point of this thread- which has wandered into the weeds) also from the payware folks...while at the same time always encountering posts from another group of folks that are dissatisfied with something or other, attracted to dissension and disagreement (mostly self-serving).
        The interesting part is that if you cross-reference these folks to the offerings in the library -- their names are often suspiciously absent. Curious, ain't it.
        One of the main reasons the OR Open Source project has gotten off the ground and made such serious strides in development and improvement is due to the co-operation of a large number of like minded folks interested in the hobby.
        To be sure there are differences and disagreements, but they are sorted out in a way quite different to the tone of this discussion.
        Best Regards to all, Gerry

        ...and by the way, if you're thirsting for "reality show" entertainment...you're already privileged to be in the greatest reality show you're ever going to participate in...just listen to that heart beat.

        My new motto: When humans learned to rise up on their hind legs, it immediately went to their heads.
        Last edited by R. Steele; 09-15-2018, 13:04.
        Cheers, Gerry
        "A mind is like a parachute. It doesn't work if it is not open." Frank Zappa
        It's my railroad and I'll do what I want! Historically accurate attitude of US Railroad Barons.
        Forever, ridin' drag in railroad knowledge.
        Audi, Vide, Tace, Si Vis Vivere In Pace​

        https://www.trainsim.com/forums/filedata/fetch?filedataid=79656&type=medium​ https://www.trainsim.com/forums/filedata/fetch?filedataid=79654&type=small

        Comment

        • emd645e3c
          Senior Member

          • Sep 2007
          • 250
          • .

          #79
          Originally posted by geepster775
          The thread needs to be closed because some participants are on their third trip around the block with the same old argument and nothing new is being added.
          Like anything on the internet, if you don't want to read it, you are free to scroll on. No one is forcing you to read it.

          I am enjoying reading other peoples stories of how Scott is doing himself out of money, as I was also a subject of his paranoia, and as a result, he lost a customer.

          Yep, it's his business, and he can run it how he wants.

          Steve

          Comment

          • CNW 5099
            Senior Member
            • Jul 2006
            • 196
            • .

            #80
            I said years ago all this hoarding would ruin the community. Private collection and modified were words that became infuriating to me in the screenshot section but what can you do, right?

            Scott has always run a pretty closed shop even when you could actually purchase his stuff without a super secret password. He had a strict repaint policy; he had to approve and they were to be hosted only on HIS site, which is fine I guess but always felt that limited sales as he didn't provide the variety of roads nor had the active release schedule of BLW who also have a limited repaint policy in play.

            Scott, at one point, was one of the sacred cows around these parts and any criticism of him and DW was met with stiff pushback. My how times have changed. And while I think his little club is stupid (pirates will always get the desired items) he does have the right to run his business as stupidly and pigheaded as he wishes. Also, many people here do operate in the same manner, as has been pointed out. You know why there is so much Indian stuff to throw tantrums about? Because they are still in that phase of community where there is no issue sharing with the general public. The American community is only sharing with their buddies, often for other rare or forbidden fruit, and the library sits devoid of new content besides a release or two here or there. Such is life.

            I think the last gasp for this simulator (on the American side) will be the Mullans Pass route (if it is still being released) as it seems to be the last significant project of note being worked on and close to completion. At that point everyone will play with the trains they have, trade exclusives, and download whatever tweaks are made to OR. My advice if you want an active, healthy and generous community you best become interested in India Rail.

            Comment

            • poochwilly
              Senior Member
              • Oct 2004
              • 107
              • Castlegar, B.C, Canada.

              #81
              I sent Scott an email months ago and his reply to me was that I didnot buy certain packs and was not entitled a code to his Private Membership Club, I have bought Diesels West stuff in the past, but I presume that wasn't good enough, not everyone has a ton of money to buy every paywares product, I have bought MLT stuff in the past, I have purchased SLI stuff in the past and also purchased Train Simulations stuff, mostly reasonably priced. Everyone seems to freaked out about piracy, its the internet, its everywhere, if you look hard enough most pay ware vendor's products are out there somewhere.

              So this Private Membership is not impressive if you have to go broke buying everything just to get an access code.

              Thanks Poochwilly

              Comment

              • MSTS lifer
                Senior Member

                • Dec 2012
                • 523

                #82
                Originally posted by poochwilly
                I sent Scott an email months ago and his reply to me was that I didnot buy certain packs and was not entitled a code to his Private Membership Club, I have bought Diesels West stuff in the past, but I presume that wasn't good enough, not everyone has a ton of money to buy every paywares product, I have bought MLT stuff in the past, I have purchased SLI stuff in the past and also purchased Train Simulations stuff, mostly reasonably priced. Everyone seems to freaked out about piracy, its the internet, its everywhere, if you look hard enough most pay ware vendor's products are out there somewhere.So this Private Membership is not impressive if you have to go broke buying everything just to get an access code.Thanks Poochwilly
                OK, we have another who at least got a reply. (Reports on that have been rare to date) And sounds like it was a decent one compared to one wcl posted.

                Comment

                • dpabrams
                  Senior Member
                  • Nov 1999
                  • 418
                  • Wyoming

                  #83
                  I have 19 packs at over $300.00 spent at DW. It didn't get me in the club and I've been bitching ever since.
                  Only you can stop Fred Flintstone wheels

                  Comment

                  • lateagain
                    2500 Post Veteran
                    • Jul 2004
                    • 2727
                    • Wareham, Dorset, U.K.

                    #84
                    Just one question to all those posting "it's his business and he can run it anyway he likes..."

                    Name me ANY other supplier of ANYTHING that you know of that adopts this business model

                    ....and BTW Gerry what folk have contributed to THIS library is irrelevant. In any case there are at least two posters in this thread who have contributed some of the best stuff in the library IMO

                    This is a payware consumer issue. I don't know about you but I never built a car! By THAT logic I'm not entitled to criticise cars or their dealership ?
                    Last edited by lateagain; 09-16-2018, 00:05. Reason: clarity
                    Geoff
                    Dorset - near The Swanage Railway.
                    UK

                    Comment

                    • ossie
                      1000 Post Veteran and Moderator



                      • May 2010
                      • 1298
                      • Melbourne, Australia
                      • MSOR

                      #85
                      Give it a rest Geoff. You can do your dog and bone routine until hell freezes over and it's not going to change a thing. Whether you like Scott's "business model" or not, the fact remains it's his and he can do with it as he sees fit and that's coming from someone who was a 24/7 member and got "benched" after making a comment in this forum he didn't approve of.

                      I genuinely feel for a number of good people I know who weren't allowed access to 24/7 or those like Pete Abrams who has contributed plenty to the hobby and plenty of cash to DW as well from what he says and I can understand their frustration and anger. That said, whether what Scott has done has been helpful overall for the hobby or not, he's one small cog in a much larger problem. Declining numbers and declining interest across the US side of the hobby have nothing to do with his decision to sell to a select group of people. The bigger issue is that we're getting older and as we lose interest or "retire", there is nothing in place to lure new people in. The Indian side of it has taken off (although when you look at the numbers of downloads of their routes and models compared to their overall population, "taken off" is an enormous exaggeration in terms) but as far as the US side goes, most likely (and sadly) if some kid is starting to explore train simulators they'll probably be drawn to one of the eye candy sims and not MSTS/ORTS despite the amazing work the ORTS guys continue to do for us.

                      There have been plenty of comments from people on both sides of this issue in this thread that do them no credit at all but equally some very valid points from people on both sides. Chief amongst them is that if people are going to be pointing their fingers at Scott, they better have their own house in order. We all know there's plenty of stuff out there that could be shared and it's not difficult to learn to do a reskin or a repaint and upload it and make a contribution if you're desperately wanting to see things move back in the direction of the "good ole days". If your only contribution is to piss and moan in the forum about how bad it all is then you'll get exactly what you're complaining about. That's a simple choice everyone can make for themselves and whether you agree with Scott or not, he's made his and another thousand pages of this thread won't change that.
                      Cheers!
                      Pete

                      Comment

                      • lateagain
                        2500 Post Veteran
                        • Jul 2004
                        • 2727
                        • Wareham, Dorset, U.K.

                        #86
                        Originally posted by ossie
                        Give it a rest Geoff. You can do your dog and bone routine until hell freezes over and it's not going to change a thing.
                        Indeed Pete I'm certain that you're right. However just VERY occasionally folk do see that they've got it wrong and change. In this case I doubt anyone is holding their breath?
                        Originally posted by ossie
                        ……..most likely (and sadly) if some kid is starting to explore train simulators they'll probably be drawn to one of the eye candy sims and not MSTS/ORTS despite the amazing work the ORTS guys continue to do for us.
                        Again this is without doubt a sad truth. The reason there are so many Brits over on ts.com now is because the New Sim "Fan Boys" took over UKTS and many UK contributors jumped aboard the newer Sims.That in itself caused a massive drop in freeware because creating stuff became harder and needed expensive software. Many former freeware contributors became "Payware" if only to recoup costs.I agree about lack of uploads but the reasons are many and various. Regrettable without doubt but not quite the same as the Payware issue? I keep hearing Scott "Shares". He doesn't share he sells …….perhaps for me and others here that should be "used to sell"???
                        Geoff
                        Dorset - near The Swanage Railway.
                        UK

                        Comment

                        • ossie
                          1000 Post Veteran and Moderator



                          • May 2010
                          • 1298
                          • Melbourne, Australia
                          • MSOR

                          #87
                          Originally posted by lateagain
                          In this case I doubt anyone is holding their breath?
                          I believe it would be a mistake if they were. Pixel trains ain't worth dying of asphyxiation over.

                          Originally posted by lateagain
                          Again this is without doubt a sad truth. The reason there are so many Brits over on ts.com now is because the New Sim "Fan Boys" took over UKTS and many UK contributors jumped aboard the newer Sims.That in itself caused a massive drop in freeware because creating stuff became harder and needed expensive software. Many former freeware contributors became "Payware" if only to recoup costs.I agree about lack of uploads but the reasons are many and various. Regrettable without doubt but not quite the same as the Payware issue? I keep hearing Scott "Shares". He doesn't share he sells …….perhaps for me and others here that should be "used to sell"???
                          Without starting a dog and bone show of my own, I get somewhat bemused by the line between the distribution of payware and freeware. Scott sells to a select group of people and whether you think that is right or not probably depends on which group you are in (or used to be in ) but his reason for doing that is JKY related. You're right, there are many factors influencing the lack of uploads here, but one of the chief reasons I read many people put it down to was also JKY and not wanting their creations to get into the wrong hands. Maybe that's true but if the last couple of years have shown us anything it's that trying to limit the access of the bad eggs to models and websites has hurt a helluva lot more good eggs and has been a major contributor to the downturn in content and participation in my opinion, whether we're talking about payware or freeware or simply people's willingness to help out new members with advice/info. I'm not criticising anyone by the way. I'm at a very flat point with trains at the moment and as far as creating and sharing reskins goes, I'm about done and understand others reach the same point. All I'm saying is that for those who care enough to be complaining about the state of affairs of our hobby, there are options if you want to put the time and effort into something positive.
                          Cheers!
                          Pete

                          Comment

                          • Rick-MONON
                            1500 Post Veteran
                            • Feb 2008
                            • 1795
                            • Elizabethtown, Ky
                            • ORTS

                            #88
                            Well, I do not think McDonalds, Walmart, Burger King and Business Internet Sites have a choice. They cannot discriminate who they sell to
                            because of what one thinks happened, who you are or who you know...............
                            Rick

                            http:\\mononrr.com

                            MONON-2

                            sigpic

                            Comment

                            • CNW 5099
                              Senior Member
                              • Jul 2006
                              • 196
                              • .

                              #89
                              Originally posted by Rick-MONON
                              Well, I do not think McDonalds, Walmart, Burger King and Business Internet Sites have a choice. They cannot discriminate who they sell to
                              because of what one thinks happened, who you are or who you know...............
                              Well it's HIS business and he can do--

                              Wait a minute, you're right!

                              By the way this is a guy who could have made a good amount of money selling his EIGHT HUNDRED MILE, extensively detailed Monon route which is pretty much a requirement for any serious MSTS/OR user. But Rick gave this to us for FREE. Imagine if he gated this route off in some super secret club.

                              So much respect and thanks to Rick.

                              Comment

                              • geekman
                                Senior Member
                                • May 2010
                                • 538
                                • Grand Rapids, Michigan

                                #90
                                Well, this is really turning out to be quite an interesting thread, and it's really opened my eyes to what various people think. Yes, I fully agree that some of you have probably been treated unfairly by Scott. I'm not sure what I can do about that except to contact Scott and ask him if he would reconsider, but in the end it's really up to him.

                                I'm happy to note that a few of you actually noticed a second point in my earlier post, and that is; "If you are going to complain about somebody limiting availability of product, you damn well better not be doing the same thing yourself." A few of you got it.

                                R. (Gerry) Steele writes "... while at the same time always encountering posts from another group of folks that are dissatisfied with something or other, attracted to dissension and disagreement (mostly self-serving). The interesting part is that if you cross-reference these folks to the offerings in the library -- their names are often suspiciously absent. Curious, ain't it."

                                And CNW 5099 writes: "...You know why there is so much Indian stuff to throw tantrums about? Because they are still in that phase of community where there is no issue sharing with the general public. The American community is only sharing with their buddies, often for other rare or forbidden fruit, and the library sits devoid of new content besides a release or two here or there. Such is life."

                                Also, Ossie (Pete) mentions it very well: "...Chief amongst them is that if people are going to be pointing their fingers at Scott, they better have their own house in order. We all know there's plenty of stuff out there that could be shared and it's not difficult to learn to do a reskin or a repaint and upload it and make a contribution if you're desperately wanting to see things move back in the direction of the "good ole days". If your only contribution is to piss and moan in the forum about how bad it all is then you'll get exactly what you're complaining about."

                                Unfortunately, others can't quite understand:

                                ".......and BTW Gerry what folk have contributed to THIS library is irrelevant..." C'mon Geoff, get with the program. It sure as hell is relevant. And for you to say "...To those "without a problem" I just hope that people are less selfish when YOU need support. What goes around, comes around." is thoughtless. I really hope you didn't mean that!

                                OK, folks, I'm stepping down off my soapbox now.
                                Larry Steiner
                                Grand Rapids, Michigan

                                sigpic

                                Comment

                                Working...