DW's Registration Code

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • lateagain
    2500 Post Veteran
    • Jul 2004
    • 2727
    • Wareham, Dorset, U.K.

    #91
    Larry


    IMO these are two separate issues.


    Firstly the thread was started asking for help with a payware site.


    Apparently many of you see no difference between Payware and Freeware?

    That I DON'T understand. Maybe because the only payware I have is ALL PAID FOR??? There are few Payware vendors I haven't bought stuff from and I have been a DW customer.


    Then there is the issue that there are MANY freeware sites, other than ts.com, and (still your side of the pond) many Payware sites.


    The idea that people selling a product are the same as people sharing freely their work is frankly just not the case as I, and I suspect many others, see it. If you are going to turn your hobby into a business then normal customer/consumer rights apply. IF you don't like that don't do it. Simple.


    My comments about selfishness were CLEARLY aimed at the disgusting gloating of a few "I'm alright Jack" posters earlier in the thread.


    The issue about not sharing freeware is another thread IMO. However it has to be said that there may be many reasons projects get shelved, they're not good enough to upload, have issues with permissions, don't get finished etc.etc.


    I'm not part of ANY "club". I have been part of a team that spent 6 years working on a UK route. I have done some reskins that haven't been uploaded for reasons above AND because real life takes first place.

    One final grouse that nobody has mentioned yet. I paid in advance for 3DTrains Sherman Hill. Originally Streamlines were supposed to be doing a stock pack. That changed to DW. Not really my era ...but how are other folk in my position going to get their stock packs?
    Geoff
    Dorset - near The Swanage Railway.
    UK

    Comment

    • CNW 5099
      Senior Member
      • Jul 2006
      • 196
      • .

      #92
      Originally posted by lateagain

      One final grouse that nobody has mentioned yet. I paid in advance for 3DTrains Sherman Hill. Originally Streamlines were supposed to be doing a stock pack. That changed to DW. Not really my era ...but how are other folk in my position going to get their stock packs?
      Hopefully the stock pack would be offered on the 3DTrains site and not subject to "club rules." Ever since West Colton I have a distaste for these route builder/stock builder partnerships. You're paying full price for a route and then you're buying packs of stock at full price just for the thing to operate. No issue for freeware routes and payware packs, you're only paying for the pack (and in BLW's case it is PACKED) and not a route plus four or five different packs to get all the activities to work.

      Does Sherman Hill have it's own 3DTrains stock or is DW supplying all of the rolling stock in it's pack?

      Comment

      • ossie
        1000 Post Veteran and Moderator



        • May 2010
        • 1298
        • Melbourne, Australia
        • MSOR

        #93
        Originally posted by lateagain
        Apparently many of you see no difference between Payware and Freeware?
        I'd had my say Geoff, but will put my oar in one last time. In my view, the only difference between payware and freeware is the cost and availability of it. Beyond that, they're all just pixel models that can be used in our hobby. CNW 5099 raises the excellent example of Rick Berg and his amazing Monon route and reminds us that Rick chose to give that massive body of work to the community for free.

        Rick's standing in this community couldn't be higher and I feel privileged to consider him a friend of mine, but hypothetically, think about this. What if Rick was just finishing Monon now and instead of giving it away for free to everyone he chose to give it to an exclusive group of people instead. In their natural excitement at their great luck in getting that route, (and assuming Rick hadn't added a caveat about keeping it quiet) they'd start discussing it here and posting screenshots and those without access to the route wouldn't react any differently to what they are in relation to Scott and his closed shop at DW would they? Would the fact it was freeware and not payware matter one bit to people who couldn't have it and as a result would people still view Rick the way they currently do, or would he suddenly become Scott MkII?

        All this talk about "business models" simply misses the point that content creators, whether they be payware or freeware, have the right to decide on their distribution method and how widespread it will be. In terms of the health of the hobby, exclusivity is counter intuitive but it is the right of the content creator, whether he's selling it or giving it away.

        I've always had an issue with permissions on freeware models. In my view, and again it has had a serious impact on the health of the hobby, if someone has given something to the community for free without a specific "no reskins etc" policy being attached, then they've left the hobby or passed away, I would have thought the natural assumption was that they would be thrilled at their work continuing to flourish. I bring that up not because I think the policy will change, but simply to highlight that all the way along the line there are "blockers" or reasons why people aren't/can't/won't "share". Scott is one of many controlling who gets what, but reading some of the comments here, you'd think he was the only one.

        You said you don't understand why some of us don't see a difference between pay and freeware. I don't understand why you do. I think when it comes to "exclusive" items floating around whether they are payware or not, we get up in arms about it because we all want what we can't have. That's human nature and whether it is Scott's stuff or the hoards of "restricted" freeware that are about the place, the pessimist in me says nothing is going to change at this late date. If anything, all this carry on will only add "value" to that content for those who have it.
        Cheers!
        Pete

        Comment

        • muskokaandtahoe
          3000 Post Veteran

          • Apr 2003
          • 3003
          • Silicon Valley, CA, USA.
          • ORTS

          #94
          Jeez, just get over yourselves, it is as-if he owes you.

          You all sound like a bunch of self-privileging losers.
          Dave Nelson
          sigpic
          Seldom visiting, posting less often that that.

          Comment

          • muskokaandtahoe
            3000 Post Veteran

            • Apr 2003
            • 3003
            • Silicon Valley, CA, USA.
            • ORTS

            #95
            Originally posted by geekman

            And CNW 5099 writes: "...You know why there is so much Indian stuff to throw tantrums about? Because they are still in that phase of community where there is no issue sharing with the general public. The American community is only sharing with their buddies, often for other rare or forbidden fruit, and the library sits devoid of new content besides a release or two here or there. Such is life."
            I didn't see the original text, only the quote....

            It's an interesting comment... is it all dues to polite shared excitement? A tendency not to cheat? Or many hundreds of millions who only recently could afford both computers and internet access? I dunno. Wish them fun.

            I do have the opinion that the US market got off on the wrong foot at the start w/o over-restrictive EULA's. Nobody should give a damn about what you do on your own PC so long as your edits stay there.

            Forget about copyright on anything that isn't art, it doesn't apply (a sound opinion but even if you disagree how many people are going to spend several tens of thousands of dollars to sue some a-hole for distributing your stuff?). There have never been all that many of us so I see file transfers mostly as a personal transaction that relies on trust.

            If you are a real jerk and abuse someones' trust, expect people to find out and treat you accordingly. Expect the abused party to tell others what happened so they can avoid you like the plague , and to be far less trusting in general going forward.

            It's a shame so much source code has been lost these past 10 years.
            Dave Nelson
            sigpic
            Seldom visiting, posting less often that that.

            Comment

            • lateagain
              2500 Post Veteran
              • Jul 2004
              • 2727
              • Wareham, Dorset, U.K.

              #96
              Originally posted by muskokaandtahoe
              Jeez, just get over yourselves, it is as-if he owes you.

              You all sound like a bunch of self-privileging losers.
              In view of this post and your first comment in your next post I suggest you start the thread at post #1. Until post#21 the purpose of the thread was quite clear. When some of those affected are amongst the most talented and generous freeware providers I'd suggest that it's not THEM that need to "get over themselves".

              A final point Scott has NOT shut up shop. The original site is still there. If every time someone tries to purchase something and there's a problem with the transaction he "bans them" I'd say that's HIS issue?

              Only had one Paypal download link fail. That was with BLW. Gaetan responded with a link within minutes. Rather different customer care wouldn't you agree?
              Geoff
              Dorset - near The Swanage Railway.
              UK

              Comment

              • ragtimer
                2000 Post Veteran
                • May 2005
                • 2009
                • Stalinist,broke United Kingdom (Hey buddy,can you spare �1.3 trillion?))

                #97
                I have bought several items from BLW.I have ALWAYS had excellent service and a link is provided if I ever need to download it again if for some reason I lose the original if I lose it or it becomes corrupted.That is what I call service.

                Comment

                • wcl
                  Senior Member
                  • May 2010
                  • 417

                  #98
                  BLW is very good, him and I talk on facebook and is a very nice guy to deal with....Just wish other vendors were as nice as he was, instead of being a hemorrhoid to deal with

                  Comment

                  • Coonskin
                    3000 Post Veteran

                    • Aug 2002
                    • 3226
                    • Poteau, OK, USA.

                    #99
                    Gaetan of BLW is a class act. We worked together to produce the "A&O Sub" route that VSC offers. He was so accommodating and quick to address any issues with his products that cropped up during development. I have nothing but respect for Gaetan Belanger.
                    Andre Ming
                    V Scale Creations.com R.I.P

                    Comment

                    • conductorchris
                      2500 Post Veteran

                      • Mar 2010
                      • 2905
                      • Vermont
                      • General

                      #100
                      I think Dave's onto something with his comments on how personal our transactions really are.

                      We have a cultural expectation that business with treat customers equally and professionally and we bring that into our expectations of payware companies. By setting up shop as companies with fancy names and so on, us payware vendors prompt those expectations. But what is really happening is more like buying art, which is typically a more personal transaction.

                      It's not uncommon for musicians and artists to have fan clubs and insider groups that get exclusive content. And certainly artists deal with copyright issues and troubled fans as well.

                      Our society really hasn't figured out how to resolve this tension between business and artistic control. It's no surprise it raises difficulties among us.

                      It is true that generosity and kindness go a long way to resolving issues. But . . . this puts the burden on the producer. The fact is the havoc that a rouge customer can cause is not priced into the transaction. (Just as true with freeware, by the way. We have less content because troublesome people made it no longer fun for some significant content producers.)

                      Christopher

                      Comment

                      • chilla
                        Senior Member

                        • Nov 2005
                        • 564
                        • Florida

                        #101
                        I'm really surprised this thread is still going all you guys just keep saying the same things over and over again and with some throwing insults at Scott.I have just one question has it changed anything have any of you got an email saying hey guy my bad here is your link to the site my bad or something along those lines.If not its probably not going to happen and all this posting bashing Scott and how he wants to do things with his stuff is a waste of your time but hey you guys haven't stopped yet so why not keep wasting more of your time fighting a battle your not gonna win.

                        Comment

                        • R. Steele
                          3500 Post Veteran

                          • Feb 2013
                          • 3928
                          • known universe
                          • ORTS

                          #102
                          Yep, it's like watching a...Train-Wreck.jpg
                          Cheers, Gerry
                          "A mind is like a parachute. It doesn't work if it is not open." Frank Zappa
                          It's my railroad and I'll do what I want! Historically accurate attitude of US Railroad Barons.
                          Forever, ridin' drag in railroad knowledge.
                          Audi, Vide, Tace, Si Vis Vivere In Pace​

                          https://www.trainsim.com/forums/filedata/fetch?filedataid=79656&type=medium​ https://www.trainsim.com/forums/filedata/fetch?filedataid=79654&type=small

                          Comment

                          • qballbandit
                            6500 Post Veteran

                            • Jan 2006
                            • 6522
                            • Elgin Il., USA.
                            • MSOR

                            #103
                            I learned one thing from this thread. How a dog feels when he's chasing his tail.
                            Neil

                            Chicago Railroading Fan

                            Comment

                            • geekman
                              Senior Member
                              • May 2010
                              • 538
                              • Grand Rapids, Michigan

                              #104
                              Originally posted by qballbandit
                              I learned one thing from this thread. How a dog feels when he's chasing his tail.
                              Great one, Neil!!! This is getting boring. Time to move on to something else, like who will end up being the Big Ten champs?
                              Larry Steiner
                              Grand Rapids, Michigan

                              sigpic

                              Comment

                              • lateagain
                                2500 Post Veteran
                                • Jul 2004
                                • 2727
                                • Wareham, Dorset, U.K.

                                #105
                                None so deaf as those who don't want to hear and none so blind as those who don't want to see.
                                Geoff
                                Dorset - near The Swanage Railway.
                                UK

                                Comment

                                Working...