TSRE Next???

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • amtrak115
    Senior Member


    • Oct 2005
    • 291
    • Parker, TX
    • General

    #1

    TSRE Next???

    maybe I missed something and if I did...i apologize. But a question....With GoKu back working on TSRE, the existance of TSRE GenX, and Eric's version .8. are the three having conversations about where the TSRE product is going! Or are we looking at another ORTS Stable version, ORTS Testing Version, ORTS MG version, and a daily build of ORTS, and I'll add PerpetualKid's verstion Trainsumlator !!!

    Just curious...

    Barry.
  • frliss
    1000 Post Veteran



    • Mar 2011
    • 1081
    • MP44.2 Worcester, MA
    • General

    #2
    Originally posted by amtrak115
    maybe I missed something and if I did...i apologize. But a question....With GoKu back working on TSRE, the existance of TSRE GenX, and Eric's version .8. are the three having conversations about where the TSRE product is going! Or are we looking at another ORTS Stable version, ORTS Testing Version, ORTS MG version, and a daily build of ORTS, and I'll add PerpetualKid's verstion Trainsumlator !!!
    That's a very good question. I'd like to know the answer myself. Just a suggestion but it would be fantastic if all three could be combined into one editor.

    Fred

    Flashing Rear End Device

    Comment

    • CSRX
      13500 Post Veteran



      • Oct 2005
      • 13649
      • Lincoln, ME
      • English
      • ORTS

      #3
      Probably the same direction we are seeing with ORTS.

      But so far, in my own opinion, ORTS V1.6 and Scott's TSRE GenX is the best of each.
      -Shawn K-
      MEC Mountain Subdivision - Trackwork 70%, Scenery 35%
      ​

      Comment

      • eric
        9500 Post Veteran and Administrator



        • Dec 2002
        • 9594
        • NS MP245.4 CNO&TP South District
        • English, SQL
        • General

        #4
        I paused any future work two months ago, and have encouraged and hope the other two will collaborate. We don't need competition, and as long as both forks publish their work to GitHub theres no reason not to take the best from both.
        If you like what you see here at Trainsim.com, be it the discussions and knowledge in the forums, or items available in our library, I hope you'll consider a paid membership to help support keeping the site operating.... Thanks!

        Comment

        • Tonya37
          Member

          • Apr 2019
          • 41
          • Perth, Western Australia
          • MSOR

          #5
          Horses for courses! I use Goku's version for terrain, Scott's GenX for tracklaying and trees (haven't tried Goku's procedural tracks yet), and often Eric's v8 because I'm used to it. We have an embarrassment of riches, and I for one am very happy that such a lot of expertise is being applied. They are *all* so well written and easy and quick to load, that it is easy to move from one to the other. I haven't even been able to explore all the features offered yet!

          Regards

          Tony

          Comment

          • niknak
            1000 Post Veteran


            • Nov 1999
            • 1254
            • UK.
            • MSOR

            #6
            Speaking as someone who only uses TSRE for adding static objects and sounds to an existing route, would there be any advantage to me in downloading one of the newer versions, Or should I simply continue with the 08..005m version I currently use?
            Last edited by niknak; 11-14-2026, 04:47.
            Regards,

            Nick

            ( ' boffin0_reprised ' on TikTok )




            Cyberpower Desktop with AMD Ryzen 5 CPU /. 16GB RAM /. ATI AMD Radeon RX6700 12GB graphics /. Windows 11 Home 64bit /. RailDriver /. Partridge in a pear tree....​

            Comment

            • pwillard
              3000 Post Veteran



              • Nov 1999
              • 3071
              • Cumming Ga
              • ORTS

              #7
              Check out GOKU's thread on Elva Tower for an example of features being added that might swing you towards that version
              http://www.railsimstuff.com
              Just Blender now, 3DCrafter only when I have to.
              Formerly The Keystone Works (All Permissions Granted)
              Things I work on: https://github.com/pwillard

              Comment

              • amtrak115
                Senior Member


                • Oct 2005
                • 291
                • Parker, TX
                • General

                #8
                Originally posted by amtrak115
                maybe I missed something and if I did...i apologize. But a question....With GoKu back working on TSRE, the existance of TSRE GenX, and Eric's version .8. are the three having conversations about where the TSRE product is going! Or are we looking at another ORTS Stable version, ORTS Testing Version, ORTS MG version, and a daily build of ORTS, and I'll add PerpetualKid's verstion Trainsumlator !!!

                Just curious...

                Barry.
                I did miss a few things...and to Scott, GoKu, and Eric, I apologize. I spent the afternoon reading through the Genx thread, and I was pleased that Goku, Scott, and Eric have had several conversations about the evolution of TSRE.

                Briefly in summary Scott's Genx version started as an attempt to fix some terrain texture issues, but has morphed into a more robust development activity...directed at a few critical items that Scott identified. Scott based his modifications off Eric's .8 version baseline so Eric's mod's could be incorporated into Genx. Along about build 8/9, Scott upgraded the framework that TSRE is built upon (QT) to the most current version, QT6. (He's now on like build 22, so lots of improvements/enhancement) He has had a plan to attack several terrain issues such as the generating Telephone Wire/poles trackside and (My apologies to Scott) a version of generating forest areas. His results have and continue to be impressive and much appreciated.

                While I'm not a route builder...more like a want to be route-builder! some of the enhancements Scott is making is leading me into more closely looking at Genx as a basis of route building in the near future.

                I've also spent some time reading through (and continue to read) several threads on Elvas Tower started by GoKu on his TSREvc version of TSRE. Again briefly in Summary, GoKu is advancing the needle using the VulKan rendering engine for graphics and a more advanced version of .NET. I was encourage to see Wayne Campbell, one of the ORTS developers using and asking Guku questions about this Advance TSRE version. As he did with the original TSRE, his new version is going to push the development/advancement of ORTS in the future in my opinion. ORTS will probably have to move to Monogame 4.x in order to take complete advantage of some of the advances that GoKu is implementing in TSREvc.

                Again to Scott, GoKu, and Eric my heartfelt appreciation of you efforts in improving/enhancing the route editing capability of ORTS. If my explanations are off and way to simplistic, I was trying to put this all into context where I could understand what's going on.

                Barry ...aka Amtrak115

                Comment

                • scottb613
                  2500 Post Veteran


                  • Apr 2003
                  • 2851
                  • Downeast Maine (soon)
                  • ORTS

                  #9
                  Hi Folks,

                  I'm still not sure what Piotr's goal is with TSRE. Is it going to remain an editor, or is it intended to become a fully realized simulator?

                  The screenshots I've seen look absolutely incredible, but unless those visuals can be brought back to Open Rails in a similar fashion, I'm not sure I see the point. Perhaps it's motivation, an impetus to drive improvements in ORTS. Maybe it's a test bed to explore what's possible with Open Rails. Either way, I can't wait to see what else Piotr has in store for us.

                  My own goal has been far less ambitious, it's to improve the systems we already have available to route builders, particularly those improvements that don't require changes to the ORTS codebase.

                  Regards,
                  Scott
                  Last edited by scottb613; Today, 08:27.
                  <a href=https://www.trainsim.com/forums/filedata/fetch?filedataid=80663&type=full title=thumb_80663.png >thumb_80663.png</a>​ My Blender Models

                  Comment

                  • amtrak115
                    Senior Member


                    • Oct 2005
                    • 291
                    • Parker, TX
                    • General

                    #10
                    Scott, I agree, I not sure what his goal is either...however there somethings that he's doing...not the graphical replay of simulations....that have a lot of applicability to current ORTS implementations. an Example is the addition of the Map View....Very similar to what you've done with the path editor of the activity editor....I know you have only done some initial work on the path editor and the rest of the activity editor is on you list. Goku additions to the activity editor also are worth noting...using the "Map" view in his TSREvc version is exactly what's needed for activity development. Adding the simulation playback (bottom of the activity editor menu) with capability to advance the time during playback is something that in my opinion needed for testing of activities without having to utilize a 3d play. I recorded the timelapse view of one of my activities that I developed...once seeing that I then went replay the activity in ORTS. attached is the replay of the timelapse activity....(it's about 11 minutes long...but you can see activity with traffic as I had planned it. )

                    having said all that...I look forward to what your next release of Genx will provide. I think your focus on improvements to TSRE for the current ORTS baseline is outstanding and I applaud your efforts.

                    Barry

                    Comment

                    • eric
                      9500 Post Veteran and Administrator



                      • Dec 2002
                      • 9594
                      • NS MP245.4 CNO&TP South District
                      • English, SQL
                      • General

                      #11
                      Piotr had said early on his intent was to have a playable game engine, but then he burned out on the development. Maybe he'll get there this time around.
                      If you like what you see here at Trainsim.com, be it the discussions and knowledge in the forums, or items available in our library, I hope you'll consider a paid membership to help support keeping the site operating.... Thanks!

                      Comment

                      • EldoradoRailroad
                        Senior Member

                        • May 2010
                        • 213

                        #12
                        Will it be the case of "too many forks spoil the broth"?

                        I am glad this topic came up, because I have been thinking about this for many months now.

                        Yeah, nice to have things moving forward that we have been waiting years for, maybe even a decade or two.

                        At some point this was going to happen if the key holders to the OpenRails project seemed too rigid and inflexible. I am not happy with seeing what might be "I am taking my toys and going home" moment. The Claude Code et all is the amplification of skill (or lack of). For those who can bother to burn through token$($$+) to deliver enhancements this is certainly most welcome to breaking the administrative log jam.

                        The fact that the right queries in an LLM can make coding rock stars for our hobby is to say the least, helpful. In the best case, it is just outstanding that the impossible is possible and "real fast now". In the worst case, unpublished source code for these enhancements leaves me wondering/worrying. In one case here there are "mystery meat" DLLs produced with a release where experience forces me to not run the program. What "AI Slop" or worse yet, lurking Trojan Horse might show up when I least expect it? Instead of jumping on the "bad wagon" I am sitting on the sidelines waiting for trouble to start.

                        I think/hope that enhancements should all be documented with source code that can be compiled to duplicate EXACTLY the new release. In the past we have had too many orphaned projects that needed updates that only had the binaries, no source code. The author "lost the source code", or simply "took his/her toys and went home". I would hate to see this with what is basically machine generated code. Where we have gone from binaries only and often out of date code, to completely hidden methods used to create these enhancements via places like Claude Code as well as the source code that the LLM created in whole or in part. If we end up in that mess, we are really no further ahead from where we were before Claude Code changed the game of software development.

                        If you are able to see the analogy, I will use pop music. Way back in the day, I know because I worked in one for awhile, recording studios had musicians come in and ply their trade putting down tracks to make a song and/or album. You could not fake it, either you play and be recorded or nothing happened. Then came the computers with MIDI and now you could fake it a bit more, that was the 1980s. Then came that beast called autotune where you did not even have to sing on key, the computer fixed your lack of talent. Move the clock forward a bit and everything is done on computers with samples of this and that, no skill required. Even worse "AI" is being used to create pop songs with no musical talent required. Well everybody has their own taste.

                        So I would like to see good software developers empowered to do more with things like Claude Code, but please, nobody is being fooled when progress is put into "warp drive". Old hands know what is going on, when too many enhancements appear way too fast, almost daily. Please be clear that the code created is through an LLM, and also please publish the code that can be compiled to create the SAME binary you have distributed. Please publish your "mystery meat" DDL source code so that nobody has to worry about unstable/dangerous code that could leave us worse off. AI is not foolproof, and will remain that way for quite some time. If anything I read how AI is being used to find as many ways to break things as a human can imagine to ask. This is not ideal at all. How is this not malicious intent?

                        Thanks for your time,
                        Steve

                        Comment

                        • eric
                          9500 Post Veteran and Administrator



                          • Dec 2002
                          • 9594
                          • NS MP245.4 CNO&TP South District
                          • English, SQL
                          • General

                          #13
                          Most of the newly developed code is in GitHub public repositories, so there should be no "black box" code in any of these projects.

                          OpenRails has been there all along, and so have all three forks of TSRE being discussed here.

                          I said this on Elvas a couple days ago: AI used as a tool is no different than how we used Stack Overflow 10 years ago, or those big paperback Dummies books were used 20 years ago. Sometimes you just need a little help to close the 10-20% when you've got 80-90% of it there.

                          Sent from my SM-S911U using Tapatalk

                          If you like what you see here at Trainsim.com, be it the discussions and knowledge in the forums, or items available in our library, I hope you'll consider a paid membership to help support keeping the site operating.... Thanks!

                          Comment

                          Working...