New Water in Open Rails

Collapse
X
Collapse
First Prev Next Last
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • BrandonS261
    Senior Member



    • Apr 2019
    • 317
    • Twin Cities
    • ORTS

    #1

    New Water in Open Rails

    Hey guys I just wanted to bring something up that I noticed lately.

    I happened to stumble across Goku's updated Route editor and decided to download it just to check it out.

    One thing that stood out to me right away was his water, sky and shadows that are much better then what we have currently in Open Rails/TSRE so my question is why can't these all be implemented into Open Rails along with Scott's TSRE?

    It would make a world of difference in the way Open Rails and the editor looks as a whole and has finally been proven that it can work if given the effort and time.

    I do need to give Scott, Eric and Goku credit where it is due because without them the route editor would not be where it is today so thank you for all of you're hard work that you have put into it.

    Here are a few shots I have taken at the same exact locations on the route I am working on using both editors to show the difference in appearance.

    Brandon

    Screenshot 2026-11-20 195702.jpg Screenshot 2026-11-18 182741.jpg Screenshot 2026-11-20 194930.jpg
    Screenshot 2026-11-18 182832.jpg Screenshot 2026-11-20 200005.jpg Screenshot 2026-11-18 181728.jpg Screenshot 2026-11-20 200142.jpg Screenshot 2026-11-18 181703.jpg
    Last edited by BrandonS261; 11-20-2026, 20:18.
  • amtrak115
    Senior Member


    • Oct 2005
    • 301
    • Parker, TX
    • General

    #2
    Brandon, I not completely sure, but the upgraded views of the textures and water in GoKu version would require an upgrade to the Monogame engine and/or possible update to the .Net Software...Of course I could be completely off too. LOL

    Barry

    Comment

    • eric
      9500 Post Veteran and Administrator



      • Dec 2002
      • 9617
      • NS MP245.4 CNO&TP South District
      • English, SQL
      • General

      #3
      "why can't these all be implemented into Open Rails"

      They can. It only takes a developer or three to commit to the integration or testing effort.

      My guess is someone does it another fork like Carlos and Monogame before it ever hits the official product.
      If you like what you see here at Trainsim.com, be it the discussions and knowledge in the forums, or items available in our library, I hope you'll consider a paid membership to help support keeping the site operating.... Thanks!

      Comment

      • railrunner112
        Senior Member

        • Aug 2008
        • 290
        • Netherlands
        • General

        #4
        As far as I know the story has two sides
        -Many people still stuck on windows 7 and 8.1 holding back progress (some even have msts still working) which kills alot of shaders potentials. Maybe it can be resolved to make certain shaders optional, maybe it can not. Who knows..
        -Many forks but not many people willing to create pull requests and follow the entire process. Just like in an IT Company with change requests all the testing, communicating and such can be a hassle and some people choose to just make their own thing.
        In the end it isn't as easy and clear as it might seem.

        Comment

        • NW 2156
          2000 Post Veteran

          • Aug 2007
          • 2291
          • Carolina's

          #5
          Originally posted by railrunner112
          As far as I know the story has two sides
          -Many people still stuck on windows 7 and 8.1 holding back progress (some even have msts still working) which kills alot of shaders potentials. Maybe it can be resolved to make certain shaders optional, maybe it can not. Who knows..
          -Many forks but not many people willing to create pull requests and follow the entire process. Just like in an IT Company with change requests all the testing, communicating and such can be a hassle and some people choose to just make their own thing.
          In the end it isn't as easy and clear as it might seem.
          I'd disagree with that statement.

          The early Kuju simulators had better water and still had Vista and Windows 7/8 support.

          Robert

          Comment

          • railrunner112
            Senior Member

            • Aug 2008
            • 290
            • Netherlands
            • General

            #6
            Fair point, trainz had better water even in different variaties per map (and skyboxes) I wishes I knew how to implement that then I would try to upload it to fit for a pull request. For now it is a bit above my skill level.

            Comment

            • BrandonS261
              Senior Member



              • Apr 2019
              • 317
              • Twin Cities
              • ORTS

              #7
              My whole point of this post is to point out that Goku has already figured out better weather and water for his route editor, he has the coding already done and its open source so why are we holding back Open Rails and the American Version of the editor for just a few people who still play on the older versions of Windows? It truely is not fair to the ones who want to get Open Rails into the modern day.

              Myself along with a few others have been pushing this for years because Open Rails needs to get with the times and open up the doors to newer technology if we want to get the younger generation involved otherwise I fear that it will die with the older generation that started with MSTS as technology advances even further and better programs come out.

              Yes we have already gone above and beyond in many areas of Open Rails but graphics is a HUGE downer when compared to Trainz and other programs out there. It would bring new light into Open Rails and make it look so much more appealing to others who are just looking for a great Rail Simulator.

              Open Rails has many things going for it when it comes to being completely free, its own stand alone program and the physics are amazing to say the least. Many great free downloads and the ability to build things in Blender are some very good things about Open Rails but the water and sky have always been a draw back.

              I know there is already work being done and has been done on weather and sky and it already looks amazing but if we were able to enhance the water as well it would just make Open Rails look so much better in my opinion.

              When I saw what Goku did with the water in his editor I was blown away and was like wait a min? If he can do that why are we not implementing this into Open Rails its self and the American version of TSRE?

              Just my thoughts and not trying to push anyone's buttons but something to really think about. Scott, Eric and Goku have been doing some amazing work for Open Rails as a whole with Eric's new track, along with the three of them working there butts off on the updated TSRE and other features them and others have put into the game over the years.

              Brandon

              Comment

              Working...