Port Ogden and Northern

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Dralex
    Member
    • May 2006
    • 45
    • .

    #1

    Port Ogden and Northern

    My favourite railway is and was always Port Ogden and Northern by Jim "Sniper" Ward. Now of course I tried to run it in OpenRails and ran into several problems. First, the runactivity.exe lists a whole bunch of errors which can only be caught in a screenshot. Mainly it was about some dynamic track portions not found. Then a system exception "the wagon is on a piece of track not found" or so. It should be fairly easy to reproduce the problem.
    After some time the simulation screen came up, and I could finally start driving. The consist I had chosen has two GP-38 back to back. These were separated by a rather big gap into which a third loco could easily have fit, but I cannot see anything there. Anyway, the whole consist started moving in the end.
    Next: at many places the trees were growing right out of the tracks.
    Also, the cursor would not be visible on the screen; only when I moved it off the game window it would be visible. Which of course prevented me from throwing switches - G and Ctrl-G would not work either.
    Finally: would it be possible to capture the output of runactivity.exe in a text file which one could then add to any error report that might come up. Might give you a lot of additional info you need to improve the program (so far it is really great, considering that you are not so long on the air).

    Greetings,
    Dralex
  • sniper297
    9500 Post Veteran
    • Nov 1999
    • 9545
    • Union Grove, Wisconsin, USA.
    • General

    #2
    PO&N? Never heard of it.

    Hey Dralex, long time no see. Few problems to start, PO&N 10 and 11 use aliased track sections, ORTS uses a different method for loading the track database, so I can't get 10 or 11 to run at all. PO&N version 9;

    ponver9.zip

    Runs as well as any other route since it doesn't have the aliased track in it.

    Other problem, you have to keep in mind that the current version of ORTS isn't even a beta, it's actually a pre alpha, so a lot of stuff isn't completely functional yet. AI traffic is rudimentary, signals don't display, and a lot of the vegetation objects will need to be moved around or rebuilt since there's something different about the numbers for centering. As for throwing switches, hold down the ALT key on the keyboard, that will make an arrow appear and you can click on any switch.
    sigpic

    Comment

    • Dralex
      Member
      • May 2006
      • 45
      • .

      #3
      Thank you, Jim. That was really quick!
      The reason why we didn't meet on the forum was that I got disappointed with RailSim (nowadays called RailWorks) because all the good stuff is payware there, in contrary to MSTS and Trainz (they are now at TS2010), where almost all the good stuff is for free.
      Now I want to have a look at OpenRails, and I like very much what I have seen so far. Some incompatibilities with MSTS are only to be expected, and your answer tells me that almost everything I noted is on their to-do list. Except perhaps my idea about putting runactivity.exe's output into a text file. I do believe this will give a lot of additional info.
      I gather Phil Skene never sent you screenies about his version of PO&N. If you want some, I can provide them, sending them to you by e-mail.

      Greetings,
      Dralex

      Comment

      • sniper297
        9500 Post Veteran
        • Nov 1999
        • 9545
        • Union Grove, Wisconsin, USA.
        • General

        #4
        But don't get me started on Rail(don't)works!

        Funny you should mention that, I just got TRS2004 as a gift last Saturday, downloaded Phil's PO&N yesterday. I have seen screens of it, right now I'm looking at it firsthand.
        sigpic

        Comment

        • Dralex
          Member
          • May 2006
          • 45
          • .

          #5
          RailWorks is not even installed any more on my computer. I hope we'll meet a bit more often now on the OpenRail platform. I am curious where this will lead us
          I am on TS2010 right now, and I like it very much. Alas, they don't support the scenarios any more (at least officially; TRS2004 is the last level where they are supported. A lot of possibilities there). So is TRS2004. Both are a lot more stable than MSTS ever was; looped rails are supported, and the front coupler always worked.
          I am also very curious about what you will make out of TRS2004.

          Comment

          • Dralex
            Member
            • May 2006
            • 45
            • .

            #6
            In the meantime we got v360, and now at least we have the switching aid, which is working ok. Trying it now on Phil's Dragon Bay route for MSTS. Not yet tried; don't know which PO&N version works with ORTS ... yet.
            One problem I would like to solve (or have solved for me): I live in Austria and have a German keyboard for that reason. This means I do not know exactly which keys to press for various purposes. The documentation assumes an English keyboard. So I know for certain that they do not test the ASCII code, but the scan code instead. I could find out for myself, but to do that I would need the source code for inspection. If somebody else could help me there, this would be the better solution.

            Alex

            Comment

            • csantucci
              Senior Member
              • Nov 1999
              • 856
              • Torino, Italy.

              #7
              Here can be found the german keys to be used:

              I hope you don't need to be registered to download it
              Unfortunately this refers only to V128.

              Carlo
              sigpic

              Comment

              • OTTODAD
                1
                • Feb 2001
                • 32344
                • England
                • General

                #8
                Hi Alex from Austria !

                I am from Vienna, in the UK since 1956.

                The keys MSTS and ORTS uses are the same, ORTS having added a few new key functions.

                The W, S, D, A, ', ;, Spacebar and other MSTS keys output from a German keyboard should be read by Windows and programs using them the same as on any other language keyboard using these characters in the language it is for.

                Some of the keys may be in different locations on the key board. like the # and @ keys but nevertheless function the same.

                Been a while since I set up my Bavarian cousin with a computer and can't remember what I had to do to use it's German keyboard.

                This might help: http://german.about.com/library/weekly/aa072798.htm

                O t t o

                Comment

                • longiron
                  1000 Post Veteran and Moderator

                  • Jan 2007
                  • 1453
                  • Just south of NYC

                  #9
                  Otto,
                  We are working on supporting international keyboard setting and custom key setting - this was raised here



                  Don't have a time frame, but it's definitely on the high priority TO DO list
                  chrisvw
                  Chris
                  "True rail fans have two favorite railroads. The B&O and one other."

                  Comment

                  • sniper297
                    9500 Post Veteran
                    • Nov 1999
                    • 9545
                    • Union Grove, Wisconsin, USA.
                    • General

                    #10
                    "don't know which PO&N version works with ORTS", disregard my previous post, they all work - versions 9 to 11 sometimes bring up an error message on loading and it appears to stop loading at that point, but recently I found that if you do nothing and wait a minute or two it loads and runs the activity anyway.
                    sigpic

                    Comment

                    • OTTODAD
                      1
                      • Feb 2001
                      • 32344
                      • England
                      • General

                      #11
                      Originally posted by longiron
                      We are working on supporting international keyboard setting and custom key setting - this was raised here: http://forums.uktrainsim.com/viewtop...f=324&t=109397
                      That link deals with the train brakes controls, # to apply them not having been mentioned in either the README.rtf nor the SoftDocs.pdf.

                      The latter could do with having it's awful yellow text changed to somehing more readable !

                      O t t o







                      Comment

                      • sniper297
                        9500 Post Veteran
                        • Nov 1999
                        • 9545
                        • Union Grove, Wisconsin, USA.
                        • General

                        #12
                        Last I heard the # to apply brakes was a misprint, it don't do squat on my Yankee Doodle keyboard.
                        sigpic

                        Comment

                        • Redcoat_1812
                          Senior Member
                          • Apr 2010
                          • 205
                          • Cymru Gorllewin

                          #13
                          Originally posted by sniper297
                          Last I heard the # to apply brakes was a misprint, it don't do squat on my Yankee Doodle keyboard.
                          Works for me on my Great Britain keyboard.
                          sigpic

                          Comment

                          • sniper297
                            9500 Post Veteran
                            • Nov 1999
                            • 9545
                            • Union Grove, Wisconsin, USA.
                            • General

                            #14
                            Oh, go pound your pound key

                            IIRC the UK keyboards have a different setup, didn't RS originally have some kind of weird thing where us Yankee Doodles had to hit the tilde or something? Anyway the only # I have is the shifted 3, which don't do anything here. ; and ' work tho.
                            sigpic

                            Comment

                            • twpol
                              Senior Member
                              • Oct 2009
                              • 434
                              • United Kingdom

                              #15
                              The V360 release of OR uses scan codes for everything, which means US layouts use ; and ' but UK layouts use ; and #. In the development versions since, this has changed so many keys are based on the actual characters (so both US and UK layouts use ; and ') plus a help window (F1) has been added listing all the keys for the various commands (using your current keyboard layout).

                              Customising the keys is on the roadmap, but we don't have a timescale for that yet.
                              James Ross
                              Open Rails Management Team
                              sigpic

                              Comment

                              Working...