BVE: YKTrain Updated

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • tydev417
    Member
    • Jan 2005
    • 95
    • Staten Island, New York, United States.

    #1

    BVE: YKTrain Updated

    YKTrain has been updated to version 1.2 a couple of days ago and can be found here, http://www.geocities.jp/yuuchankellyy/indexe.html but sadly turned into shareware($20) . It also isn't compatible with BVE 4.
  • J_Legrand
    Senior Member
    • Oct 2003
    • 136
    • Switzerland.

    #2
    RE: YKTrain Updated

    *Aheeemmm* Since when you can make a shareware addon for a <u>freeware</u> game ?

    Comment

    • tydev417
      Member
      • Jan 2005
      • 95
      • Staten Island, New York, United States.

      #3
      RE: YKTrain Updated

      I'm also wondering if they're allowed to do that.

      Also, I'm not the creator of this program.

      Comment

      • Robertj
        Member
        • Jul 2004
        • 42
        • Maassluis Centrum, The Netherlands.

        #4
        RE: YKTrain Updated

        I think that you can make commercial add-ons for a freeware game, not much wrong with that. But you are not allowed to modify files that come with the original program without at least a permission.

        Comment

        • J_Legrand
          Senior Member
          • Oct 2003
          • 136
          • Switzerland.

          #5
          RE: YKTrain Updated

          Hmm, I'm just wondering, because YKTRAIN use freewares routes to run.
          That's like an shareware program which one work only with freewares, it's illegal, basically.
          And anyway, how come an author can make profits from a freeware ?
          What would happen if a route author ask players to buy it ? That's the same with YKTrain, i guess, because this program depend from BVE, at least from BVE files.

          And that's pretty l*me to make profit from a from a freeware, even if YKTrain as a lot of potential.

          That's would be a nightmare if BVE become a shareware, at least for me :-D.

          Comment

          • TomBeevers2000
            Senior Member
            • Nov 1999
            • 475
            • Doncaster, I apologise that we, United Kingdom.

            #6
            RE: YKTrain Updated

            I would suggest YKTrain going shareware is a *very* dodgy option... AFAIK it cannot function without BVE?

            --
            Tom Beevers
            http://brj.rr.nu - Picc v5.2 Coming Soon

            Comment

            • womer_uk
              Senior Member
              • Apr 2003
              • 398
              • Bradford, Yorkshire, England.

              #7
              RE: YKTrain Updated

              suppose it doesn't really matter, can't see the author will make enough profit to buy a bubbly off the penny tray in the paper shop LOL :-) :-)

              John

              Comment

              • fcancalon
                Member
                • Aug 2006
                • 75
                • Warsaw, Poland.

                #8
                RE: YKTrain Updated

                Hello,
                More generally, let us regret that BVE, so extraordinary, is not proposed under 'open source', allowing the best specialists amongst us (I am not one of them due to my reduced quantity of neurons) to propose some improvements, ensuring the future of BVE. For instance, the only real difference between BVE and MSTS is the possibility to see a train from the outside (to have 'mobile' crossing trains could be a cherry on the cake).
                I am sure that nothing in the BVE design prevents from designing such an extension, as shown by YKTrain (I will not discuss here about shareware vs. freeware).
                YK train is interesting but implies a lot of adaption to the routes (and probably the rolling stock). Isn't possible to imagine the same topic, more open? A sort of BRR?
                François

                Comment

                Working...